This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Last week I argued that friction is a feature of learning, not a bug — the struggle is the mechanism. This week: which friction to keep, and which to kill without a flicker of guilt.

But before you decide that I'm the old guy claiming he walked uphill both ways in the snow to school — no. That was my dad's tall tale. I also believed he knew Santa and the Easter Bunny. But I digress.

Parents have been mythologizing friction for generations with “back in my day….” Now as their kids inherit a world engineered to remove it entirely, they are reasonably worried whether that world is helping or hurting you to reach your potential.

Somewhere between their friction brag and the frictionless feed is the honest middle. Let's find it together.

Negative Friction: Kill It with AI

Some friction teaches you nothing. It's just sludge. Here's what that may look like in your week, and exactly how to wipe away the sludge:

You're stuck at 11 p.m. on a calculus concept with no one to ask. Prompt ChatGPT: "Act as a tutor. Do NOT give me the answer. Ask me questions to figure out where my understanding breaks, then give me hints one at a time." The old 11 p.m. problem was a tall wall with no ladder. That's the friction AI should demolish — notice the prompt keeps the climb.

You spend two hours formatting citations instead of strengthening your argument. Paste your source list into a Google Doc and prompt Gemini: "Format these sources I found into an MLA works-cited page." Then spend the two hours you got back on your argument — the part that earns the grade and makes you better. A good rule of thumb: AI formats sources you found. Never let it invent sources, because it may try.

Your assignments live across many platforms — Canvas, email, a class website, and three group chats. Add connectors and prompt Claude: "Here's everything posted this week. Build me one list of what's due, ranked by deadline, with where to submit each one." Stop the never-ending archaeology dig for your own homework.

You re-read a dense chapter four times because you're dyslexic, not because the ideas are hard for you. Use Speechify’s AI text-to-speech to turn the textbook chapter into audio — listen on the bus, at the gym, wherever — then prompt: "Let me explain this concept back to you and tell me what I missed." Ideas are not your barrier. The printed page is.

You're scheduling the group project with a fourteen-message thread. Prompt Copilot: "Here are five people's availability. Find every window when all five overlap, and draft a two-sentence message proposing the best one." Fourteen messages become one answer.

Negative friction steals time from learning, growing, or just having fun. Remove it and don't look back.

Positive Friction: Protect It like Your Social Security Number

Then there's the friction that IS the learning:

  • Retrieving an answer from your own memory before checking

  • Writing the first ugly draft yourself — so that over time, your first drafts stop being ugly

  • Sitting with a problem long enough to explore solutions, because problem-solving is the valued skill

  • Having the awkward conversation instead of sending the AI-polished text.

The skill of the next decade isn't simply using AI. It's knowing which kind of friction you're standing in before you decide to reach for the tool.

Context Is Everything

Here's where the AI-in-education debate goes off the rails: people talk about "learning" like it's one thing. It's at least four, and the friction rules are different for each.

  1. Complex skills — writing, coding, analysis, problem-solving. This is where offloading is most tempting and most expensive. Wharton's Ethan Mollick — who is very much pro-AI — draws a hard line here: "education is different – the effort is the point."

And he references empirical data to back it up. In an experiment at a high school in Turkey, students given ChatGPT for math homework did the homework better and were confident they were learning more. At test time, they underperformed the students who never had AI. Read that again: they did better on homework, felt smarter, and knew less. Then a large-scale study in China found the same pattern at scale: when AI use cuts homework time, test scores drop right along with it. The tools that helped students complete the practice in less time also cancelled the positive impact.

A footnote to that same Turkey experiment really speaks volumes. They had a second AI group, using a version prompted to behave more like a tutor, with hints and guardrails instead of immediately serving up answers. For those students, the harm mostly vanished: they tested about the same as classmates with no AI at all. Hold this thought that will be the entire plot of Part 3: Do the reps yourself. Use AI as a tutor, never a stunt double.

  1. Rote procedural skills — long division, formatting, boilerplate stuff. Once you truly understand a concept, grinding reps forever is mostly negative friction. If you are a finance major, you need to learn algebra and accounting. Learn it, practice it, prove you can do it — then, and only then, automate it with Copilot’s Agent Mode within Excel and Intuit Intelligence within QuickBooks.

  1. Memorizing content — dates, vocabulary, anatomy, formulas. There is a plot twist here: AI is fantastic for memorization, but only if you use it to add friction. Gemini Notebook quizzing you mercilessly with flashcards and retrieval practice is desirable difficulty on tap. You can rewrite questions, fix answers, and add new cards from scratch. It works on mobile too, so you can steal time anywhere to practice. There's also a new "study notebooks" feature in the Gemini app that runs diagnostic quizzes and builds personalized lessons — including SAT prep. But if you only use a chatbot for "what's the answer," it becomes a forgetting machine with a friendly interface.

  1. Human skills — negotiation, empathy, leading the group project when Kyle hasn't even opened the doc. There's no shortcut, because the friction of real humans is the curriculum. AI can help you red-team your position and rehearse the hard conversation. But it cannot do the rep of an actual disagreement with Kyle, who has actual feelings. Is he just lazy, or is he distracted by his girlfriend who just dumped him? Being empathetic and learning how to find others’ motivations — particularly when you are stressed out, annoyed, and trying to meet a deadline — are human skills that will serve you well in both your professional and personal life.

Four different verdicts using AI. Did you notice that memorization got the opposite answer from complex skills, and rote skills flipped verdicts mid-category, depending on whether you'd learned the concept yet? Anyone offering you a one-sentence take on AI and learning now can learn something from you.

The Sorting Question

Before accepting anyone's verdict on AI and learning, ask them one question: which kind? You’ll be able to tell right away whether they thought about it as hard as you just did.

And before every prompt you type into a chatbot, ask yourself a version of that question: is this friction building me, or just annoying me? Fair warning — that's much harder to answer than it sounds, because all friction is annoying. I spent my childhood insisting I hated learning. Turns out I just hated friction, and I couldn't tell the difference. Many people never learn to.

Next week, the fun part: how to flip AI from friction-remover to sparring partner. We will discuss using it to create the friction that builds you up. It turns out the same tool that will happily write your essay will also happily refuse to, if you know what to ask it.

Don't surrender. Start sparring. See you next week.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate